Rising Floodwaters Trapped Me on a Stagecoach Roof With the Man Who Murdered My Brother.
And Only One Rope Could Save Us Before the Coach Rolled.
"Pull the rope back!"
I screamed toward the canyon rim, my boots sliding across the slick wooden roof as muddy water battered our wheels.
"He murdered Luke in cold courage, and I will not let him escape across that line first!"
The heavy iron grappling hook struck the roof slats between us with a hollow thud.
Above us on the sunlit sandstone ledge, the canyon scout braced his boots against an old cedar root, holding the taut line steady.
Beside me sat the prisoner in coarse burlap headgear, his wrists locked tight in heavy iron cuffs.
To understand why I was stranded in a raging canyon wash with my brother's killer, I must return to noon.
My name is Clara Mercer.
Two days ago, my brother Luke was murdered at our family way station.
And the county sheriff placed a hooded prisoner onto the express coach for transport to Moab.
I boarded the roof to make sure the killer never slipped away.
But ten miles south of town, a wall of flash flood water roared down Devil's Fork, sweeping the horses downstream and wedging our coach onto a mid-river boulder.
Within minutes, the river rose five feet, tearing away the driver's bench.
Only one hemp line reached us from the rim before the boulder gave way.
I grabbed the prisoner's collar to shove him aside, tearing the burlap hood from his head in the blinding sunlight.
But the face staring back at me wasn't the town outlaw Frank Tolliver.
The sunlight hit the prisoner's pale face, and my breath caught in my chest.
He was not Frank Tolliver.
He was Jonah Vance, the twenty-year-old stable hand who had worked at our way station since the previous spring.
His eyes were swollen with tears, and purple bruises darkened his cheekbones beneath the dirt.
"I did not harm Luke!"
Jonah sobbed over the thunder of the rushing floodwater.
"Tolliver broke into the barn at midnight and demanded the strongbox keys!"
"When Luke refused, Tolliver struck him down with an iron wagon wrench!"
I gripped Jonah's coat, my mind spinning as the brown torrent surged over the lower windows of the stagecoach.
"Then why were you hooded and chained in this coach?"
I shouted the question back at him.
"Tolliver is the deputy's cousin!"
Jonah cried out, holding up his iron-bound wrists.
"They locked this hood over my head and told the town I was the killer so Tolliver could ride out with the cash!"
A violent shudder racked the stagecoach as the river swept away the front axle beneath us.
The coach listed fifteen degrees to the right, muddy water swirling across the roof slats.
Up on the canyon ledge, twenty feet above the foaming rapids, Travis the scout leaned over the rim.
"The boulder is rolling!"
Travis yelled the warning through cupped hands.
Travis ordered us to clip the line and jump.
I looked from the fraying hemp rope to Jonah's shackled hands.
If he leaped into the current with bound wrists, the weight of the iron would drag him under instantly.
I reached into the leather pocket of my skirt and pulled out Luke's folding pocketknife.
I jammed the blade into the gap between his wrist cuffs, prying at the rusted lock pin with all my strength.
The metal pin snapped free with a sharp click.
Jonah tore his hands free, rubbing his raw skin as the wooden roof beneath us tilted another ten inches.
The rear wheels tore free with a sound like snapping gunfire, swept into the churning foam downstream.
"You jump first, Jonah!"
I secured the hemp knot around his chest with both hands.
"I am not leaving you on this carriage!"
Jonah yelled back, his voice firm despite his shaking legs.
"Take the line together!"
Jonah grabbed my arm so we gripped the thick hemp rope with all four hands just as a massive pine log crashed into the carriage body.
The boulder rolled beneath the impact.
The stagecoach tipped sideways, rolling like a hollow barrel into the roaring brown depths of the canyon wash.
The rope went taut with a bone-jarring snap.
We swung together across the boiling foam, suspended between the rushing water and the sheer red canyon wall.
The river spray struck my face like a shower of freezing needles.
Above us, Travis strained against the cedar root, his boots slipping on the slick sandstone.
"Climb hand-over-hand!"
Travis roared the command down to us.
Jonah reached above my hands, finding purchase on the knotted hemp and pulling upward.
His strength surprised me, his boots finding small footholds in the red rock fissures.
Together, we scrambled up the last ten feet of vertical stone, hauling ourselves over the rim just as the stagecoach vanished beneath the foam.
We collapsed onto the warm, sunbaked sandstone of the plateau.
I lay on my back, watching the clear blue desert sky spin above me while my heart hammered against my ribs.
Jonah sat up on his knees, shivering violently in his soaked shirtsleeves.
He reached inside his heavy leather work boot and pulled out a small brass object wrapped in oilcloth.
He peeled back the cloth with trembling fingers.
It was Luke's personal brass pocket watch, engraved with our family brand on the silver casing.
"Tolliver dropped this in the straw when he broke into the office,"
Jonah whispered, handing the watch to me.
"I hid it inside my boot before the deputy handcuffed me."
"Tolliver's initials are scratched right into the brass clasp where he tried to pry it open."
I held the cold metal against my chest, tears finally breaking past my eyelids.
The watch was absolute proof of Tolliver's guilt.
Travis walked over, coiling the remainder of the wet grappling line over his shoulder.
"Tolliver took the high trail toward the Green River ferry,"
Travis said, looking south across the mesa.
"He thinks Jonah is drowning in the canyon with the stagecoach."
"How far ahead is he?"
I asked the question while standing upright.
"Two hours on a tired horse,"
Travis answered, pointing to two spare pack mounts tied in the juniper brush.
"We can cut him off at the canyon ferry before the boat crosses."
Jonah stood up beside me, his jaw set with quiet, steely resolve.
"Let me ride with you, Clara,"
He said.
"I want to see the town marshal put the irons on Tolliver's wrists."
We mounted Travis's trail horses and rode hard across the sunlit mesa, skirting the flooded ravines through the red dunes.
By late afternoon, the sun was casting long golden shadows across the Green River landing.
A solitary rider in a gray duster was leading a lathered horse onto the wooden ferry barge.
It was Frank Tolliver, clutching a canvas saddlebag stuffed with the way station funds.
Travis spurred his mount down the embankment, levering his rifle into the air with a deafening crack.
"Step off the barge, Tolliver!"
Travis barked the command across the water.
Tolliver whirled around, his hand reaching for the holster at his hip.
"Drop the rifle, Frank!"
Jonah rode out into the clear afternoon light where every ferryman could see his face.
"You thought the river drowned me, but I am standing right here with Luke's watch!"
Tolliver's face drained of color as he looked at the living witness he believed was lost in the gorge.
The ferryman quietly stepped behind the timber capstan and unhooked the mooring line, trapping Tolliver on the open barge.
Seeing three rifles trained on his chest and the proof in my hand, Tolliver slowly raised his hands into the sunlight.
Two deputy marshals from the river station stepped out of the ferry office and fastened heavy iron irons around Tolliver's wrists.
Luke's stolen funds were recovered to the last dollar.
Jonah was cleared of every charge before the sunset had faded from the canyon cliffs.
And Luke's brass watch now ticks steadily in my pocket, a reminder that the river took our stagecoach.
But the truth refused to drown.
More Stories You May Enjoy
- I Chased a Runaway Freight Car on an Iron Handcar Under Blazing Noon Sun—Only to Realize Someone Had Deliberately Cut the Brake Chains.
- I Was Sinking Waist-Deep in Canyon Quicksand at High Noon—And Begged a Passing Stranger to Save the Leather Case Before He Pulled Me Out.
- I Clung to a Broken Pine Root in Dazzling Morning Snow—Begging a Mountain Trapper to Save the Brass Tube in My Pack Instead of Me.